Historical Archive

Archive | 1935

Eddie belongs to the popular culture of pulp magazines, jazz rooms, newspapers, erotica, stag reels, and bar talk. Eleanor belongs to the curated world of psychoanalytic journals, case histories, classical music, oil painting, museums, and professional diagnosis. The Velvet Trap brings those worlds together: popular culture becomes analytic material, academic knowledge becomes erotic charge, and both women learn to see desire through each other.

Listen while you read

Let the room play in the background.

Start the playlist before you enter the archive. Immerse yourself in a world moving from Prohibition to Swing - urban, polished, hungry.

Playlist & Scroll
Enter the Archive

Choose a door.

Some historical sources use pathologizing or offensive language about sexuality and gender.

The Sound of the Trap

The night has a rhythm.

The sound world of The Velvet Trap captures the personalities. For some, there is smoke, flirtation, and performance. For others, there is discipline, longing, and reflection.

Spotify playlist

The Velvet Trap Playlist

A 1935 mood playlist for The Velvet Trap: dance-band glamor and torch-song ache.

Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, Op. 43: Variation No. 18 Andante cantabile

Sergei Rachmaninoff · 1934

Haunted and romantic. This brings Eleanor to tears in the Trap library with Eddie.

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No. 5 - 4. Finale

Willem Mengelberg · 1928

Eleanor's favorite symphony. She and Eddie have it playing at Christmas.

The Forbidden Library

Erotic manuals and censored fiction that shaped the novel's secrets.

The Case History of Desire

Sexology and psychoanalysis supplied the period vocabulary of inversion, neurosis, perversion, and diagnosis.

R. von Krafft-Ebing · 1893 English edition

Psychopathia Sexualis

Krafft-Ebing's categories of “contrary sexual instinct,” perversion, sadism, masochism, fetishism, and inversion helped shape the vocabulary of sexual deviance. Freud explicitly draws on Krafft-Ebing, while also transforming the material.

In the novel, Eleanor knows this book as part of the world that trained her, and its language of diagnosis and deviance press uncomfortably on her own life. Desire is speakable — and dangerous.

Havelock Ellis · 1897

Studies in the Psychology of Sex, Vol. II: Sexual Inversion

One of the major sexological texts through which early twentieth-century readers encountered homosexuality as a medical and psychological category. Ellis’s case histories gave same-sex desire a language of classification and diagnosis — a language that could seem humane for its time.

In the novel, Eleanor knows this literature as part of her training and culture, but she also knows its danger: the same language that lets doctors discuss forbidden desire can also be used to expose and condemn it. Eleanor reads to Eddie from CHAPTER IV.—SEXUAL INVERSION IN WOMEN.

Dr. Jacobus X · 1900 medico-legal sexual science

The Psychopathy of Love: The abuses, aberrations, and crimes of the genital sense

Published in Paris by C. Carrington, this medico-legal compendium gathers a sexual taxonomy that treats desire as evidence: inversion, sadism, masochism, fetishism, and sexual crime become part of one diagnostic and legal vocabulary.

In the novel, this book disturbs Eleanor. It's primarily of interest in legal and institutional settings.

Sigmund Freud · 1905 / 1920 English edition

Three Contributions to the Theory of Sexuality

Freud’s early and disruptive theory of sexuality. Perversion is no longer treated only as a category of criminal, degenerate, or pathological persons. Freud makes the more dangerous claim that perversity belongs to sexuality itself--in childhood, fantasy, symptom formation, and ordinary erotic life.

In the novel, this gives Eleanor a language that is more flexible than Krafft-Ebing’s taxonomy and more intimate than Ellis’s case histories. Freud lets her think about Eddie’s desire as history: shame, defense, childhood memory, and repetition.

Magnus Hirschfeld · 1914

The Homosexuality of Men and Women

Hirschfeld’s major sexological study treats homosexuality as a natural variation rather than a crime or degeneration.

In the novel, Eleanor can think differently about same-sex desire: still period-bound, still scientific in its claims, but less punitive. His work also carries the shadow of war. By 1935, the destruction of Hirschfeld’s Institute for Sexual Science by the Nazis makes this knowledge feel politically charged as the world was heading in a more conservative direction.

Sigmund Freud · 1915 / 1924 English translation

Observations on Transference-Love

Freud’s central technical paper on erotic transference and analytic danger. The essay takes up the situation in which a woman patient falls in love with the doctor analyzing her, turning the consulting room into a site of longing and professional temptation.

In the novel, Freud gives the rule Eleanor knows she must obey: the patient’s love must neither be gratified nor dismissed, but held within the treatment. Eleanor knows the theory. She knows the warning.

Sigmund Freud · 1919 / 1920 English translation

“A Child is Being Beaten”: A Contribution to the Study of the Origin of Sexual Perversions

Freud’s essay on beating fantasies is one of his most important papers on fantasy, punishment, and the formation of perversion. It traces how a childhood scene can be disguised and preserved as an adult erotic structure, where pleasure and humiliation become difficult to separate.

In the novel, this paper gives Eleanor a way to think about shame and desire. Eddie’s erotic life is about how childhood fear has been rearranged into ritual and control.

Sigmund Freud · 1920

The Psychogenesis of a Case of Homosexuality in a Woman

Freud’s major case paper on female homosexuality presents the desire of a young woman for an older woman. The essay is limited by its period assumptions, but it treats female homosexuality as psychically complex.

In the novel, this paper gives Eleanor a professional precedent for thinking about female desire, parental authority, identification, and forbidden attachment.

William Stekel · 1922

The Homosexual Neurosis

Not innate in the Hirschfeld “third sex” sense, but a psychogenic neurosis. Homosexuality as a neurosis that psychoanalysis may sometimes cure by uncovering blocked bisexuality and fear of the opposite sex until heterosexual love becomes possible. The neurosis arises from disgust for opposite sex, narcissism for a similar body, a retreat caused by sadism toward the opposite sex.

In the novel, Eleanor cites Stekel for his ability to "cure" homosexuality. This is a book Eleanor knows, uses cautiously, resists privately, and fears being measured by.

Fritz Wittels · 1924 English edition

Sigmund Freud: His Personality, His Teaching, & His School

Wittels was Freud’s first biographer and an early member of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society. His account presents Freud as commanding authority and the movement’s drift toward discipleship. Femininity, narcissism, homosexuality, and the “child-woman” shows psychoanalysis speaking boldly about sex while still turning women’s desire into a problem to be explained by men.

In the novel, Eleanor read Wittels as professional history and warning. By 1935 Chicago, the same problem has taken an American institutional form: psychoanalysis is becoming professionalized, policed, medicalized. Desire may be spoken, but only under supervision.

Karen Horney · 1926

The Flight from Womanhood: The Masculinity-Complex in Women, as Viewed by Men and by Women

Writing from inside psychoanalysis, she questions the habit of treating female development as a derivative or failed version of male development.

In the novel, Horney gives Eleanor a language of resistance from within her own profession.

Sigmund Freud · 1927 / 1928 English translation

Fetishism

Freud’s short paper on fetishism became one of the central psychoanalytic texts on perversion as disavowal. Fetishism is a psychic arrangement built around loss, denial, and compromise.

In the novel, Freud’s paper offers Eleanor a theory of fetishism as structure, though it is tied explicitly to male development.

Ernest Jones · 1927

The Early Development of Female Sexuality

Jones’s paper is one of the major early psychoanalytic texts on female sexual development. The difficult question of how women’s desire could be described without being reduced to deficiency.

In the novel, one of Jones’s disguised clinical examples draws on Eleanor herself, turning her into psychoanalytic material. She knows the prestige of being close to theory, but she also knows the violence of it: a woman’s desire can become a footnote, a professional case made by someone else.

Edward Glover · 1928

The Technique of Psycho-Analysis

A practical account of analytic technique from the London psychoanalytic world: the analytic situation, resistance, transference, interpretation, and the analyst’s own counter-resistances. Technique is disciplined procedure shaped by timing, restraint, and the handling of what the patient brings into the room.

In the novel, Glover belongs to Eleanor’s professionalism, the technical authority she respects and hides behind: the rules of the consulting room, the pressure of transference, and the danger that the analyst’s own wishes may enter the work.

Helene Deutsch · 1930

The Significance of Masochism in the Mental Life of Women

Deutsch’s influential paper on femininity, frigidity, reproduction, and masochism. Written in the authoritative language of early psychoanalysis, the essay treats feminine development through penis envy, the castration complex, maternal fantasy, sexual inhibition, and the psychic relation between womanhood and suffering.

In the novel, this is a text Eleanor has to know, use, and resist. She can speak that language when she must: clinically useful, socially protected.

Sándor Ferenczi · Presented 1932 / German publication 1933 / English translation 1949

Confusion of Tongues Between Adults and the Child | The Language of Tenderness and of Passion

Ferenczi’s late and controversial paper on trauma, seduction, and the analyst’s responsibility to recognize the child’s language of tenderness rather than forcing it into the adult language of passion.

In the novel, Eleanor reads German and still follows the European analytic journals. Before this paper and throughout his oeuvre, Ferenczi gave a humane counter-tradition: more responsive, challenging the frame. However, citing him also exposes her. At the Institute, his active technique and his challenge to Freudian authority mark the line between courage and heresy.

Sándor Rado · 1933

Fear of Castration in Women

A severe example of the period’s conservative psychoanalytic theory of women. Rado treats female sexuality through lack, penis envy, genital masochism, frigidity, fear, and failed adaptation to a prescribed feminine role. Female ambition, homosexuality, intellectual work, and resistance to men are pathology.

In the novel, this paper gives Eleanor the professional language she has to navigate even when she hates what it does. Rado belongs to the theoretical atmosphere pressing on her: womanhood as injury, desire as defect, and every refusal of heterosexual femininity as something to be explained away.

James Strachey · 1934

The Nature of the Therapeutic Action of Psycho-Analysis

A major paper on what actually makes psychoanalysis work. Strachey argues that interpretation is not merely explanation, but a mutative act: a carefully timed intervention in the transference that lets the patient experience the analyst as different from an archaic feared or desired object.

In the novel, Eleanor shares a quote with Eddie before their first erotic encounter. The paper clarifies the power of interpretation, but it also exposes the risk: the analyst becomes the object of the patient’s impulses, and the treatment depends on whether she can survive that position without using it for herself.

M. E. Opler · 1935

The Psychoanalytic Treatment of Culture

An early essay at the border of psychoanalysis and anthropology. Is culture merely the background of psychic life, or are prohibition, ritual, and belief already part of the symptom before the patient enters treatment?

In the novel, Eleanor reflects on Opler in a case conference, a way to think about a racial encounter.

Karen Horney · 1935

The Problem of Feminine Masochism

Horney’s challenges the assumption that masochism is naturally or essentially feminine. She turns toward culture, dependency, social training, and the ways women are taught to find safety, value, or love through self-sacrifice.

In the novel, this essay gives Eleanor crucial counter-language for thinking about punishment, erotic suffering, and the social training of women. How much of what appears to be feminine submission is created by the world that demands it?

Ernest Jones · 1935

Early Female Sexuality

Jones’s returns to one of the central disputes in psychoanalysis: whether female sexuality should be understood through lack, penis envy, and the phallic phase, or whether girls possess an earlier and more complex femininity of their own.

In the novel, the article arrives in the same months that she is trying to defend her own authority.

Franz Alexander and William Healy · 1935

Roots of Crime: Psychoanalytic Studies

Alexander and Healy’s study shows psychoanalysis entering the worlds of medicine, courts, delinquency, and public order. Inner life becomes something that can be examined for criminality, abnormality, and social danger. Psychiatrists suggested that such disturbances were the cause of sexual deviance.

In the novel, this book gives the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis its authority through its first director, Dr. Franz Alexander. Alexander makes psychoanalysis powerful by making it useful to the institutions that classify, correct, and contain. Eleanor’s danger is less the psychoanalytic scandal than the lesbian relationship.

Melitta Schmideberg · 1935

Reassurance as a Means of Analytic Technique

A strikingly modern paper arguing that reassurance isn't a failure of technique. Reassurance as a way to dose anxiety, support the ego, acknowledge reality, and make interpretation possible when a patient is too frightened, distrustful, or overwhelmed to use it. This is a lovely paper that threads theory and very likely personal experience with having every phastasy made into evidence--the author is the daughter of Melanie Klein.

In the novel, this paper gives Eleanor humane but dangerous professional language for what she already wants to do: answer the patient, ease panic, bend the frame, and believe that analytic care can include a real human response. It also highlights the conflict with Victor, who sees exactly how easily reassurance can become gratification, rescue, or enactment.

Paintings, Bodies, and Looking

Paintings, illustrations, and photographs that shape the novel’s gaze.

Saints, Shame, and Ritual

Prayer, martyrdom, punishment.

Religious language and ritual discipline form part of Eddie's emotional and symbolic inheritance.

Catholic prayer

The Rosary Prayers

Eddie's red-brown rosary on an antique wooden table

The rosary is a prayer of repetition: bead after bead, decade after decade, while the mind returns to the same words. For Catholics of Eddie’s world, it belongs to private devotion, family discipline, parish life, and the long habit of obedience.

In the novel, Eddie’s rosary is something held, counted, worried, and carried. Its rhythm echoes the other rituals that shape her—confession, penance, restraint.

Roman Catholic hand missal · Pre-Vatican II

Roman Missal: English and Latin

Pre-Vatican II Roman Catholic hand missal with English and Latin text

A lay missal used by Catholics to follow the Traditional Latin Mass from the pew. With Latin prayers and English translation, books like this helped parishioners track the priest’s words, feast days, responses, and ritual movements.

In the novel, Violet carries a hand missal and follows along at Mass. The book belongs to the world of parish respectability: gloves, veils, kneelers, and the management of what a woman appears to be.

Jacobus de Voragine · medieval saints' lives

The Golden Legend: Saint Sebastian

Vintage holy card image of Saint Sebastian pierced by arrows

A saints' life tied to martyrdom, beauty, bodily suffering, and the religious imagination of the punished body.

In the novel, Eddie makes an allusion to Saint Sebastion surviving the Arrows with respect to how she dealt with her mother.

Traditional Catholic devotion · pre–Vatican II form

Litany of St. Sebastian

A private devotional litany to Sebastian as martyr, soldier, sufferer, and protector against plague. Its older Catholic language gives Eddie a form of speech shaped by obedience, endurance, and bodily suffering.

In the novel, Eddie’s attachment to St. Sebastian isn't abstract piety. The arrows, the wounded body, and the repeated response become a way to speak pain without naming desire directly.

Life in 1935 Chicago

How they lived.

Films, recordings, and practical fragments of 1935.

RKO Radio Pictures · 1935 Top Hat Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers at full Depression-era polish: white tie, hotel rooms, mistaken identity, sexual charm, and dance. Eleanor and Eddie enjoyed the glamour while noticing everything it refused to say directly.
Universal Pictures · 1935 Bride of Frankenstein Bodies made and rejected, scientific ambition, social disgust, and a monster who wants companionship. Eddie loved the danger. Eleanor noticed the pathos before admitting how much of the queer coding she understood.
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer · 1935 Mutiny on the Bounty A prestige picture of cruelty, discipline, and rebellion. Its posters plastered Eddie’s downtown Chicago: Gable’s face over the Loop.
Gustav Machatý · Czechoslovakia · 1933 Ecstasy / Extase A scene from Ecstasy with Hedy Lamarr (then Kiesler) a film burned when it entered the U.S. in 1935. Some nudity, even more threatening, it was a woman's search for pleasure. This scene was notorious for showing a woman having an orgasm. Vivian screens a bootleg copy for the four women in the novel's mise en abyme: a forbidden film reflecting the importance of desire and female self-possession. ABOUT THE FILM
Internet Archive · 1934 Maniac / Sex Maniac A 1934 exploitation horror from the world of sensationalized psychiatry and crime. Insulting to Eleanor and Eddie's introduction to psychoanalysis.
Internet Archive Getting His Goat A 1920s stag reel. By 1935, stag films still moved through smokers and after-hours bars. Vivian uses stag films and other non-cash currencies to keep men’s goodwill. Eddie learns the practical economy.
Video archive Benny Goodman Big Band Remote From the Congress Hotel Chicago Original Air Date Was 12/23/1935. This originally aired on NBC's Red Network, at Midnight EST.
Internet Archive · 1933 Chicago World’s Fair 1933 Footage from the Century of Progress Exposition, which closed the year before the novel begins: crowds, lights, modern buildings, and a lakefront spectacle. Some fair structures remained.
Vanity Fair page titled Impossible Interview: Dr. Freud vs. Jean Harlow, illustrated by Miguel Covarrubias

Vanity Fair · May 1935

“Impossible Interview: Dr. Freud vs. Jean Harlow”

A satirical magazine page from 1935, with Freud turned into a comic celebrity analyst and Jean Harlow transformed into the glamorous patient on the couch. The satire catches psychoanalysis at the exact cultural moment Eleanor inhabits: prestigious enough to parody, but already vulgarized into a public fantasy of exposure and inhibitions.

Technology

Telephones, records, cameras, lights, and machines.

Clothing

From daring to drab.

Getting Around

Streetcars, cars, the L, and walking the city.

Food & Drink

Cost, convenience, cocktails, and class.

Work

Newspapers, hospitals, laundries, offices, and service.

Home Life

Boarding houses, Hyde Park houses, and Gold Coast rooms.

Religion & Respectability

Mass, marriage, reputation, and public virtue.

Medicine & Psychoanalysis

Symptoms, consulting rooms, hospitals, and forbidden knowledge.

Entertainment

Films, dancing, pulp, music, art, and nightlife.

Vice & Secrecy

After Prohibition, police, coded names, and hidden doors.

↑ Top